Thursday, August 29, 2019

The Problem with Physics is Physicists


If you don't believe in the existence of God, you don't become a priest. If you don't believe in the existence of mass, you don't become a physicist. Mass is God to physicists. 

A physicist will tell you that mass has a material existence and a perceived existence. It's just an age-old philosophical disagreement between the Realists and the Idealists. Idealists are skeptics who are inclined to think the material world does not exist, but rather our senses of perception play mind games that make us think things exist when in fact all we can say is that we merely perceive things (e.g. to touch a table is to say our sense of touch perceives it, but our sense of touch does not go so far as to validate existence). Realists on the other hand are believers who are inclined to think the material world exists even though it would not have to actually exist in order to be perceived, and of course they have no proof that it does exist.


Many unexplained observations based upon Newton's first law resulted in senseless theories that were ultimately explained away by the theory of relativity. Remember the planet Vulcan (no, not the one from Star Trek) that invisible planet between Mercury and the Sun which was used to explain why the orbit of Mercury didn't follow Newton's first law?  While the theory of relativity invalidated Vulcan, it didn't actually invalidate Newton's first law but rather narrowed it to non-inertial reference frames. Now we sit with this peculiar notion of invisible dark matter that must exist based upon Newton's second law when in all likelihood it too will be explained away with a narrowed scope of validity. Perhaps this narrowed scope will redefine mass just as the theory of relativity redefined space and time. Would a physicist actually go so far as to define mass as something that has only a perceived presence rather than something that actually materially exists?  We keep hearing of terribly confusing experimental results that on one hand the scientific community is willing to recognize since they obtained the results via their own accepted methods, yet they struggle to explain them since they only make sense if mass doesn't exist at all.

For example there is the issue of entanglement. It seems confounding that a pair of particles can behave identically even after they've been separated by large distances. In reality it's only confounding if those particles actually materially exist. Imagine a live local news broadcast, and the weather radar map comes up. That same map comes into view (virtually) simultaneously on tens of thousands of television screens across separated by large distances. Of course the weather map doesn't exist in the television screens as it does in the television studio, but it doesn't have to in order to be perceived. 

 
It seems particle physics experiments are getting denser and denser to the point where I'm not even interested in keeping up anymore since they are not actually growing outward. Just like a particle, a tomato can be dissected and its reactions tested in thousands of experiments, but if it's not sitting on the vine, you can never observe the photosynthesis that causes it to ultimately grow. Just like Newton's first law could not explain everything outside of our earthly reference frame without being connected to the greater properties of time and space, a tomato cannot explain cannot explain all of its properties without being connected to the vine. The photosynthesis analogy comes to mind since physicists/biologist can't define the details of photosynthesis either, but there's some thought that entanglement theory might hold an explanation. Hmmm...

 
It's time to stop nano-examining what's in front of us and let the research move outwards. Physics is begging for an expanded look into material mass vs. perceived mass. This would require a physicist to completely remove the idea of any particle or aspect of energy assuming a physical existence, and it might be tough to get the research funds for an experiment based upon such an hypothesis. Perhaps it's time to acknowledge our technology has come to the point where there exists a branch between physics and metaphysics. Until that happens, the problem of stagnation of theoretical physics remains with the physicists.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Do you have any of your own observations to add?